Just Group, Plc. (LSE:JUST) - Overview & Highlights
Justifying a 50% Upside & Prime Takeover Target Case - Just Group Investment Screener Summary
Brief Business Description
Just Group plc is a specialist UK financial services company focused on the retirement income market. It provides guaranteed income for life, primarily through defined benefit (DB) pension plan de-risking solutions (80% of business) and personal annuities, known as Guaranteed Income for Life or GIFL (20% of business). The company leverages a predictable profit spread between its high-quality assets and guaranteed liabilities.
Key Financial Snapshot (£ Millions, unless stated)
Core Investment Highlights
Undervalued & Open Shareholder Structure: Trades at approximately half its "locked-in" book value (TNAV of 254p vs. share price of 148p), significantly discounted compared to peers like Legal & General. High float (98.84%) signifies no controlling shareholder, making it an attractive takeover target.
Pure-Play UK Retirement Specialist: The only listed pure-play UK retirement company, offering deep specialization in a vast and expanding market.
Massive & Growing Market: Serves a £1 trillion+ DB market with annual transactions around £50 billion, and a £7 billion per annum personal annuity market.
Predictable "Locked-In" Business Model: Assets and liabilities are locked in for an average duration of 12 years, providing highly predictable cash flows. If new business ceased, existing cash flows are estimated to be worth twice the current market cap.
Strong Profitability & Growth: Achieved 36% new business premium growth in 2024 (£5.3bn), leading to a 34% rise in underlying operating profit (£504m). Targets "mid-teens or above" IRR on new business and over 15% underlying ROE.
Conservative Capitalisation & Efficient Growth: Robust Solvency II ratio of 204% and low new business strain (1.3% in FY 2024) support self-funded growth and capital returns.
Investment Thesis & Market Context
Just Group presents a compelling investment opportunity as a leading specialist in the high-growth UK retirement income market. Its significant undervaluation relative to its Tangible Net Asset Value (TNAV), coupled with its dominant niche, predictable "locked-in" cash flows, and open shareholder structure, creates a strong and undeniable case for a takeover. The investment thesis hinges on the market recognizing its underlying economic value, which may not be fully captured by traditional IFRS metrics.
Market Context: The UK Retirement Market
DB Scheme De-risking Trend: Companies are increasingly offloading pension scheme risks to specialists like Just, driving demand for bulk annuities.
Growth of Defined Contribution (DC) Pots: A growing cohort of retirees managing substantial DC pension pots increases demand for retirement income solutions.
Supportive Consumer Duty Regime: Mandates that financial advisors offer attractive and appropriate products, favoring guaranteed income solutions.
Interest Rate Environment: Higher interest rates generally make annuities more appealing and can improve DB scheme funding levels, accelerating de-risking.
Just Group's Strategic Positioning
Just Group differentiates itself through its singular focus and expertise. It specializes in:
Pure-Play Focus: Solely dedicated to the UK retirement income market.
Niche Specialization: Targets the "smaller deal size end of the market" for DB de-risking where competition is less intense.
Medical Underwriting Expertise: In the GIFL market, it specializes in medically underwritten annuities for individuals with long-term illnesses or higher health risks, allowing for accurate pricing and competitive terms.
UK Concentration: Management is committed to organic growth only within the UK, recognizing ample opportunities domestically.
Competitive Advantages, Moat & Business Model
Just Group possesses a narrow economic moat derived from:
Specialized Underwriting Expertise: Built over years for medically underwritten annuities and complex DB schemes, hard to replicate.
Strong Risk Management Framework: Excellent credit default history, sophisticated asset-liability management, and prudent use of reinsurance (70-90% of longevity risk reinsured).
Regulatory Acumen: Successfully navigates the stringent UK regulatory landscape (PRA, Solvency II), acting as a barrier to entry.
Brand and Trust: Developed reputation as a specialist in long-term retirement security.
"Locked-In" Business Model: Assets and liabilities are locked in until maturity (average 12 years), providing predictable revenue and profit streams from its "Profit Spread."
How Just Makes Money
Its business model is straightforward: it profits from the "Profit Spread" between what it earns on its High-Quality Assets (fixed income products matched in duration to liabilities) and what it pays on its Guaranteed Liabilities (the guaranteed lifetime payments).
Virtuous Cycle: The company operates on a "Virtuous Cycle" of:
Low Strain (efficient capital utilization in new business) → High Growth → Profit Generation → Capital Creation (facilitating further low-strain growth and shareholder returns), underpinned by "Continuous Improvement."
Industry Attractiveness & Competition (Brief Porter's Summary)
The UK retirement market is structurally attractive but demanding, characterized by high regulation and competition. Just's high barriers to entry protect its incumbency.
Power of Suppliers (Capital providers, Reinsurers): Moderate.
Power of Customers (Pension schemes, Individuals): Moderate.
Barriers to Entry and Exit: High (8/10). Due to substantial capital requirements (Solvency II), stringent regulatory hurdles, and specialized expertise needed.
Intensity of Rivalry: High (7/10). Several large, established players and new entrants, leading to some tightening of spreads. However, the market is large enough for disciplined players to find profitable business.
Threat of Substitutes: Moderate (5/10). Income drawdown products for individuals; buy-ins, longevity swaps, or self-management for DB schemes.
Overall Score & Comment: (32/50). The market is large and growing with high barriers protecting incumbents. Just's niche focus and strong risk management allow it to thrive in a competitive environment.
Financial Performance Summary & Capital Allocation
Revenue Trends & Drivers:
Strong New Business Premiums: £5.3 billion in 2024 (36% increase over 2023), driven significantly by DB de-risking.
IFRS Total Revenue: Grew from £186.1m (FY22) to £449.7m (FY23) and £471.9m (FY24).
New Business Margins: 8.7% in FY 2024, slightly down from 9.1% due to business mix, but still targeting mid-teens IRR.
Margins and Profitability:
Underlying Operating Profit: Rose 34% to £504 million in 2024, representing the economic reality of new business and in-force profit.
IFRS Net Profit (Parent): Volatile, from -£381.9m (FY22) to £129.0m (FY23) and £80.0m (FY24).
Underlying ROE: Aiming for over 15%, reported 15.3% for FY 2024.
New Business Strain: Low at 1.3% (FY24), well within the target of below 2.5%, indicating high capital efficiency.
DuPont Analysis (IFRS Basis Trends) - Note: Discrepancies exist between PBT-based ratios and reported IFRS Net Profit ROE, highlighting complexities of insurance accounting.
(Calculated ROE using PBT/Sales * Sales/Assets * Assets/Equity * (1-Tax Rate) for 2024 is approximately 6.24%, differing slightly from the reported 6.53% IFRS ROE, indicating the nuances of insurance accounting where underlying economics are emphasized).
Capital Allocation & Shareholder Returns
Organic Growth Focus: Solely focused on organic growth within the UK.
Growing Dividends: 20% increase to 2.5p per share for FY 2024, demonstrating commitment to shareholder returns.
Strong Solvency Maintenance: Consistent focus on maintaining a robust Solvency II ratio (204% at FY 2024).
Management Snapshot
Experienced Leadership: Led by David Richardson (Group CEO since Sep 2019, 0.31% ownership), a seasoned actuary and CFA charterholder. Mark Godson (Group CFO since Jan 2024) and John Hastings-Bass (Non-Executive Chairman since Aug 2020) complete the experienced leadership team.
Consistent Strategy: Management is highly regarded for its disciplined focus on organic, UK-only growth.
Director Dealings: CFO and NEDs have purchased shares recently, while CEO had a sale in April 2024 (viewed in context of significant holding and positive assessment).
Valuation Glimpse
Deep Discount to TNAV: Trades at ~0.58x its Tangible Net Asset Value (TNAV) of 254p per share, while its nearest peer (Legal & General) trades around book value.
Inherent Value: The in-force book's cash flows (discounted at 6%) are estimated at twice the current market cap if no new business were written.
Upside Potential: Trading at NAV would imply a doubling of the share price. TNAV is also expected to continue growing strongly.
Analyst Outlook: Consensus price targets of 165.00p to 219.00p imply 11% to 48% upside from current levels.
Key Drivers, Risks & Conclusion
Key Performance Drivers:
Continued DB De-risking: Ongoing trend of companies transferring pension liabilities.
Growth in DC Market: Increasing need for retirement income solutions from growing DC pots.
Consumer Duty Regime: Regulations favoring transparent, guaranteed income products.
TNAV Re-rating: Potential for share price to close discount to its growing TNAV.
Increased Investor Awareness: Active investor relations efforts to communicate the story.
Takeover Target: Strong M&A rationale due to deep undervaluation and open shareholder structure.
Key Risks Summary:
Persistent Undervaluation (Value Trap): Risk that the discount to TNAV persists without a catalyst.
Crystallization of Risks: Longevity risk (mitigated by reinsurance), interest rate declines (primarily for new business), credit defaults (mitigated by high-quality portfolio), unforeseen regulatory changes (less likely for existing business), and inflation (mitigated by linked assets/swaps).
Intensified Competition: Could lead to margin compression, though Just's niche focus helps.
Management Missteps/Departure: Deviation from strategy or loss of key personnel.
Complexity of Financials: IFRS accounting can be opaque, leading to investor confusion.
Just Group is fundamentally driven by its significant undervaluation relative to its strong and growing Tangible Net Asset Value. As the UK's only pure-play retirement insurer, it benefits from strong structural tailwinds in a large and predictable market, underpinned by its "locked-in" business model and highly efficient capital management. The company's strong underlying profitability and an experienced management team further solidify its appeal. The meeting point of a deeply discounted valuation, growing intrinsic value, and an open shareholder structure creates an undeniable logic for a takeover, suggesting that shareholders may realize value through an acquisition sooner rather than later. Just Group warrants serious consideration for investors seeking exposure to a high-quality, undervalued specialist in a defensive sector.
If you like this post please consider subscribing to The Small Cap Strategist.
This post is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered investment advice. The author is not a financial advisor. All investment decisions carry risk, and readers should consult with a qualified financial professional before making any investment choices. The author may or may not hold positions in the securities discussed.